Pole axed: Microsoft and XP, Apple and Porn

Pole axed: Microsoft and XP, Apple and Porn

Having queried his readership, Cringely relays his findings on OSes, innovation, online censorship, and the iPhone

Over the past two months my minions and I have been running surveys on the BuzzDash home site and the Tynan on Technology blog to take users' temperature on issues such as censorship and innovation. Now it's finally time to report on what we've found. The results may surprise you.

First Question: If someone built an Internet free from pornography, would you come? (Hold your dirty jokes to the end, please).

With 375 votes tallied, the score is "Yes" 22 per cent, "No" 61 per cent, and "Define pornography, please" with 17 per cent. In other words, three-quarters of Netizens either don't want or don't trust ISPs or Uncle Sam to filter the Net. No big surprises there, IHMO. Johnshier comments:

"Ewww. I'm really disgusted that 25 per cent of the people voted yes. I'm just as disgusted if not more so at the people who think that judgment is needed to define pornography. I am strongly against censorship in all its forms."

Question Deux: You're buying a new OS. Which one would you pick?

More than 400 people responded to this one, and the results are: Windows Vista (13 per cent), Windows XP (70 per cent), Linux (8 per cent), and the Mac OS (9 per cent). Frankly, this one surprised me. Oh, I knew Vista would take it in the shorts, but I expected a stronger showing by the Mac OS. The Apple fanboys were probably too busy trying to get MobileMe to work to weigh in. Commenter Austin says,

"I run XP on four machines and Ubuntu on another machine. Hell will freeze over before I install Vista. Dell's customer support may stink to high heaven but their marketing is smart to continue selling XP."

Question the third: "Complete the following sentence: The Apple iPhone is...."

Here's a real shocker. "God's gift to geeks" (24 per cent) lost to "Overhyped and underpowered" (57 per cent). Didn't see that coming. Sixteen per cent of our 160+ voters consider it just another smart phone, and the rest responded "What's an iPhone?" (You people really need to get out more.)

Finally, Question IV: "What company has created the most innovative technology?"

This was a much tighter race than I'd anticipated. With 128 votes counted, Apple leads with 35 per cent, followed closely by Google (30 per cent) and Microsoft (25 per cent). Sony and Palm bring up the rear. I thought Apple and Google might split the vote, but I'm shocked Redmond registered so high. Then again, maybe I picked the wrong mix of companies. Someone calling him/herself The Geekster suggested a lineup of "Intel, Apple, Xerox, and Motorola." Not a bad call. Maybe we'll use that for a future poll.

Follow Us

Join the newsletter!


Sign up to gain exclusive access to email subscriptions, event invitations, competitions, giveaways, and much more.

Membership is free, and your security and privacy remain protected. View our privacy policy before signing up.

Error: Please check your email address.
Show Comments