Please wait while the page is being loaded Skip this advertisement >
Tuesday | 9 September, 2008
ARN
OS Smackdown: Linux vs. Mac OS X vs. Vista vs. XP
Four experts defend their chosen operating systems in an opinionated free-for-all
Related Stories
  • +

    Vista SP1 is ready -- or is it? 05 February, 2008 08:08:28

    Crucial service-pack code wraps, but when will users get it? That's the question
    Just a little more than a year after its first crack at Vista, Microsoft Monday announced that Vista 2.0 -- officially Service Pack 1, or SP1 -- has gone final -- just as had been rumored over the weekend. Officially it's gone RTM, which is Microsoft-speak for "release to manufacturing." That's code for done, as in signed off, as in shipped out for duplication and distribution.
  • +

    Give your computer the finger: Touch-screen tech arrives 04 February, 2008 08:38:37

    Time to kiss your mouse goodbye?
    The WIMP human-computer interface may have an uninspiring name, but Windows, Icons, Menus and Pointing devices have dominated computing for some 15 years. The keyboard, mouse and display screen have served users extraordinarily well.
  • +

    Would a Microsoft-Yahoo deal out Google Google? 02 February, 2008 09:32:47

    Bid is riddled with pitfalls and benefits, analysts say
    As Microsoft tries to take on search company Google for more advertising revenue by offering to acquire Yahoo Inc., a big question remains: Can Microsoft and Yahoo together best Google?
  • +

    The LAN turns 30, but will it reach 40? 01 February, 2008 09:20:52

    ARCnet idea came to an engineer while he was eating a meatball sandwich
    LAN technology recently passed a milestone -- it's been around for 30 years, some of them tumultuous. But while the LAN seems ubiquitous now, there are those who think its future may be more troubled than its past.
  • +

    Device breaks the low-end NAS wide open 01 February, 2008 08:25:40

    "Impressive"
    I've been on a bit of a green kick around here for the past few months. A computer lab is notoriously power hungry, with servers running at 100 percent utilization for days on end, generating traffic or running test harnesses. There are certain areas where I can make some reductions, however, such as collapsing a half-dozen less-utilized boxes onto a single VMware ESX server. There are some other ways, too.
Additional Resources
ARN Library

Newsletter Subscription

Sign up for our ARN newsletters!
The premier provider of daily news to the IT channel, covering business, technology, products, and services.
RSS Feeds

Since the dawn of time -- or, at least, the dawn of personal computers -- the holy wars over desktop operating systems have raged, with each faction proclaiming the unrivaled superiority of its chosen OS and the vile loathsomeness of all others.

No matter how fierce the language or convincing the arguments, however, these battles began to seem somewhat irrelevant to regular working stiffs. While Mac OS, OS/2, Linux and many other desktop operating systems have all had their devotees over the years, the truth is that the majority of home and business users have simply used the current version of Windows as a matter of course.

Windows Vista has changed all that. Never has a Microsoft operating system been greeted with such a lack of enthusiasm from consumers and businesses alike. Whether it's because of Vista's confusing array of versions, its hefty hardware requirements, its driver issues or its invasive security features, users are resisting the upgrade to Vista and considering other options, from Mac OS X to Linux to just sticking with Windows XP, thank you very much.

Suddenly, the OS wars have a new relevance.

That's why we've asked four US experts to lay out their best arguments in support of their desktop operating systems of choice:

  • James Turner for Linux

  • Michael DeAgonia for Mac OS X

  • Preston Gralla for Windows Vista

  • David Ramel for Windows XP

Each is positive that his operating system is the best and will try his hardest to convince you of that -- and is not above taking a few swipes at the competition. These are not rational, disengaged reviews; these are opinionated essays meant to sway your point of view.

-- Valerie Potter

Market Place

ARN Member Login

 
Panel Sessions
  • ARN Panel Sessions: Day 3

    The last of our panel sessions recorded live at CeBIT 2008. Today, the topic is storage. Data is growing at an enormous rate, so what does the future hold?

Play
ARN news
  • Weekly Tech News Update: 8th September, 2008

    We're back again at the IFA consumer electronics show in Berlin where a virtual mirror helps you see the latest fashions, Samsung introduces a laptop that's lighter than air, and a prototype LCD TV is the thinnest on the show floor.

Play
Channel Watch
  • Brian's bloopers

    It takes a long time to produce an episode of Channel Watch. Maybe you'll understand why after watching this...

Play
Business Continuity & Disaster Recovery Zone

When an IT disaster occurs, how handy it would be to push a button and start again as if nothing had happened.
Discover and learn more about CA XOSoft today.
ARN Vendor Directory
ARN Library

WebCentral boosts Security and Reliability with Windows Server 2008

WebCentral, Australia's largest web and application hosting company, relies on Microsoft Windows Server 2008 to deliver the security, manageability and reliability their customers require.

Sponsored Links