Please wait while the page is being loaded Skip this advertisement >
Monday | 13 October, 2008
ARN
In memoriam: the ISV
The trend was most apparent this year in data analysis software, where the fallen include Pilot ... So is it the end of the business ISV as we know it?
Related Stories
  • +

    The year ahead 21 December, 2007 06:47:49

    ARN takes a look at some of the industry's top technology and trend predictions for 2008
    Unified communications and IP telephony, virtualisation and SMB were on the lips of almost every IT vendor this year, but what will be the biggest technologies and trends next year? ARN asked a cross-section of the community for their predictions on what would be hot in 2008.
Additional Resources
ARN Library

Newsletter Subscription

Sign up for our ARN newsletters!
The premier provider of daily news to the IT channel, covering business, technology, products, and services.
RSS Feeds

The world of business software continued its inexorable march toward Total Consolidation in 2007. If IBM was off the mark in 1943 when it (supposedly) predicted a world with only five computers, it might have better luck today with a similar prediction about the software industry.

The trend has been under way for years, but the past 12 months saw many of the remaining big names in business software absorbed into other companies, including Hyperion, Business Objects, Cognos, Opsware and webMethods. They join PeopleSoft, Siebel, JD Edwards and JBoss from the recent past. Outside of security companies, it is now difficult to name even a half dozen well-known, best-of-breed vendors that are holding their own.

The trend has been driven by two factors: First is the commoditization of key software sectors, including Java middleware and business intelligence, where products that once were distinct and innovative started to look remarkably the same. Second is the need by big platform vendors like IBM, SAP and Oracle, to take over new markets as growth in their own businesses -- databases and applications -- dries up. Buying companies with mature products and a lot of customers gives them a fast and safe way to do that.

The trend was most apparent this year in data analysis software, where the fallen include Pilot Software (to SAP), Hyperion (Oracle), Inxight (Business Objects), OutlookSoft (SAP), Applix (Cognos), Cognos (IBM) and Business Objects (SAP). Other prominent names swallowed up were Telelogic (IBM), Xensource (Citrix), Agile Software (Oracle), Altiris (Symantec) and WebEx (Cisco).

But you can't say they didn't warn us. Larry Ellison, Oracle's rapacious CEO, has made it his favorite pastime this decade (after sailing) predicting the demise of the independent software vendor. "There won't be, and nor does there need to be, tens of thousands of software companies," he said at OracleWorld in 2002, before launching a torrent of scorn on startups like Ariba, Commerce One and i2 Technologies. Ariba's e-commerce software was so simple, he said, "two cats could have written it."

Ariba, ironically, is among the survivors, as is i2 (although it is considering a possible sale), and Commerce One was acquired last year. But then, predicting the future is easy when you fulfill the prediction yourself. Oracle has done more than any other vendor to consolidate the industry, buying close to 40 companies in three years.

Not that all of those companies tried to resist Oracle's tractor beam. PeopleSoft put up quite a fight and BEA, which Oracle tried to buy in October, has resisted (for now). But in many cases, Oracle was "an exit strategy for startups looking at a weak IPO market or a weak stock market," said Forrester Research analyst R. "Ray" Wang.

So is it the end of the business ISV as we know it? In fact, probably not. For starters, some large independent vendors remain, like SAS, Sage, Lawson Software, Dassault Systemes and BEA. There are several reasons for their survival: SAS is privately owned, so less vulnerable to the type of shareholder pressure that shoved BEA onto the market. Some others lie only on the fringes of commoditized segments.

"It is indicative that the BI vendors acquired in 2007 were those that focused on performance management and traditional BI functionality," said Vuk Trifkovic, an analyst with Datamonitor. "Vendors trading primarily on less commoditized predictive analytics, such as SPSS and SAS, remain independent."

More importantly, as sure as yesterday's technologies mature and get acquired, so a new wave of startups -- in virtualization, software-as-a-service or enterprise Web 2.0 -- will grow to become large ISVs and begin the cycle anew. "Pure-plays will always be there, as long as innovation takes place in a given market," said Bo Lykkegaard, a research manager with IDC.

In the meantime, what's a large business to do? Customers should have pointed discussions with their primary vendors about their future plans, said Wang. The type of discussion will vary depending on the vendor.

"On the SAP side, it's really about understanding what they're trying to do on the technology front," he said. "SAP acquisitions will be things that bolster NetWeaver. ... If you're an IBM customer, the question for them is, 'Are you going to acquire some of these applications I own, and how should I prepare for that?'''

Market Place

ARN Member Login

 
Panel Sessions
  • ARN Panel Sessions: Day 3

    The last of our panel sessions recorded live at CeBIT 2008. Today, the topic is storage. Data is growing at an enormous rate, so what does the future hold?

Play
ARN news
Play
Channel Watch
  • Brian's bloopers

    It takes a long time to produce an episode of Channel Watch. Maybe you'll understand why after watching this...

Play
Business Continuity & Disaster Recovery Zone

When an IT disaster occurs, how handy it would be to push a button and start again as if nothing had happened.
Discover and learn more about CA XOSoft today.
ARN Vendor Directory
ARN Library

NAB works with Avanade® to leverage Microsoft® Windows Server® 2008 for its branch offices

In 2007, Avanade helped the National Australia Bank use Windows Server 2008 to simplify deployment, maximise the efficiency of their low-bandwidth wide area network and consolidate its IT infrastructure.

Sponsored Links