Is profit the only driver to recycling e-waste?

Experts say no, as product stewardship plays into the equation

Recycling of e-waste has been a hot topic in the IT industry for many years, but questions have always been raised whether recycling will happen if there is no profit involved.

The problem two decades ago with paper was that companies would not buy recycled paper because it was cheaper to buy pulp from the mill, leading to warehouses being full of unused paper.

James Bradfield Moody, author of the book The Sixth Wave, admits that in many cases it is cheaper for companies to buy the raw product than do the recycling, but this mindset is no longer sustainable.

“There are mega trends in effect around resource efficiency, and scarcity will be the focus of the next 30 years,” he said.

“Ultimately, the recovery option will become more efficient than the notion that it will be cheaper to dig it out of the ground.”

That being said, Moody concedes that the profit motive is a strong one, but adds that it is not the only one.

For one, there are institutional, legal and behavioural mechanisms that can also influence behaviour.

To illustrate his point, Moody points to the overall shift to public transport, where car ownership in the US hit a peak last year and started to go down.

“The reason for that is not because cars are more expensive, but people decided that they did not want to waste their time driving a car,” he said.

“There are lots of other things they could be doing while sitting in a bus, such as tweeting.”

Issues such as whether people can afford the petrol remain, but Moody said the biggest factor for people to prefer to use public transport is the other things they could be doing instead of driving a car.

“The more profit motives you can find, the more institutional mechanisms you can get to line up the better,” he said.

“There are these other levers that can be potentially be pulled, and some of them are quite effective.”

Undertaking stewardship

Product stewardship regulator section assistant director, Michael McGee, said that the Product Stewardship Act, which came into action in August 2011, is designed to aid with this.

“Product stewardship recognises that industry should cover the costs towards recycling where it is not cost effective in itself,” he said.

McGee admits that the scheme is very expensive for the industry, but it is one approach in terms of ensuring recycling takes places where profit is not the major driver.

“If the product is valuable enough to be recycled, you may not need a product stewardship program in the same way,” he said.

Patrick Budmar covers consumer and enterprise technology breaking news for IDG Communications. Follow Patrick on Twitter at @patrick_budmar.

2014 ARN Women in ICT Awards - Nominations close October 27!: Nominations have opened for WIICTA 2014 and will stay open until October 27. But don't be late, be among the first in and NOMINATE NOW!!!

Tags eWastetechnologyrecycling

More about IDGIDG CommunicationsIDG CommunicationsIDG Communications

Comments

Comments are now closed

 

Latest News

Oct 24
20th Century Fox deploys HP Moonshot servers
Oct 24
Adobe begins encrypting user data collected from Digital Editions app
Oct 24
St George turns on fingerprint login for Apple iOS Internet banking
Oct 24
DDoS attacks skyrocket: Akamai State of Internet Report
More News
29 Oct
NewLease & Microsoft Technical Sessions
30 Oct
Ovum 2020 Telecoms Summit
30 Oct
NewLease & Microsoft Technical Sessions
05 Nov
vForum 2014
View all events