Instagram takes a hit, but users may be too addicted to quit

Instagram takes a hit, but users may be too addicted to quit

Though it backtracks from proposed policy change, damage has been done

After backing off a controversial change to its Terms of Use policy, Instagram may have avoided a debacle but is still taking a big hit to its once glossy image.

Analysts, however, say users are probably too addicted to what is becoming one of their favorite social media sites to make the company suffer.

Late on Thursday, Instagram co-founder Kevin Systrom announced in a blog post that executives would sack the change and revert back to the original policy.

The move came after a user uproar over the changes that included allowing Instagram to use or sell user photos and information for advertisement deals. Angry Instagram users vented their frustrations on Twitter and some high-profile users, like singer Pink and National Geographic vowed to stop using the service.


Earlier this week, Systrom posted in a blog that the brouhaha was all a misunderstanding and he asserted that the company, which was recently bought by Facebook, would not be selling users' photos without consent.

Even so, Instagram's planned Terms of Use policy stated, in part: "To help us deliver interesting paid or sponsored content or promotions, you agree that a business or other entity may pay us to display your username, likeness, photos (along with any associated metadata), and/or actions you take, in connection with paid or sponsored content or promotions, without any compensation to you."

Among others, Dan Olds, an analyst with The Gabriel Consulting Group, didn't buy the explanation. His view earlier this week was that Instagram was backpedaling more than clarifying.

Then last night, Instagram scrapped its plan for a new policy all together.

Patrick Moorhead, an analyst with Moor Insights & Strategy, said that Instagram has in one week tarnished its once gleaming image.

"I think they're looking foolish," said Moorhead. "It's good they backed off or it would have been a debacle. It would have been a face-off between consumers and Instagram. And when you're supposed to be a friendly social media site, that's never a good thing. It's something that could torpedo your brand."

Instagram's image has taken a big hit, he said.

"I think people originally had thought of them as this small, successful, friendly startup and now they don't look any better than Facebook or Google...," he said. "There was some purity that Instagram had. It's not just me. I believe that they've taken a chunk out of their brand."

Rob Enderle, an analyst with the Enderle Group, agreed that Instagram has burned itself.

"Instagram appears to subscribe to the theory that learning from others' mistakes isn't nearly as much fun as learning from your own," he added. "In one single foolish decision, they destroyed a large portion of their value."

Both Enderle and Ezra Gottheil, an analyst with Technology Business Research, said Facebook, which has more than its share of user uprisings, is getting a good chunk of the blame for Instagram's mess.

"I think it will occur to many people that Instagram did not have a reputation for sudden thoughtless moves, and Facebook does," said Gottheil. "This was pretty bad. They reminded users that they are just units of production."

However, none of the analysts think this will be a long-term problem for Instagram. After all, Facebook remains, by far, the largest social network in the world.

"I think there will be a short-term hit..., but I don't think this will have major long-term implications," said Moorhead. "For many people, it's like a drug. They just love it."

However, he said, if users have lost a sense of trust with Instagram, they may be more apt to try out alternatives.

Sharon Gaudin covers the Internet and Web 2.0, emerging technologies, and desktop and laptop chips for Computerworld. Follow Sharon on Twitter at @sgaudin, on Google+ or subscribe to Sharon's RSS feed. Her email address is

See more by Sharon Gaudin on

Read more about social media in Computerworld's Social Media Topic Center.

Follow Us

Join the ARN newsletter!

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags Internet-based applications and servicesInstagramnational geographicsecuritytwittersocial mediainternetprivacy



IN PICTURES: Nutanix's .NEXT channel event in Sydney (+20 photos)

IN PICTURES: Nutanix's .NEXT channel event in Sydney (+20 photos)

Nutanix recently held its customer and channel event, .NEXT, in Sydney. The event, held at the Sheraton on the Park saw attendance from more than 150 channel and technology partners and customers. It was the first in a series of events Nutanix is holding in A/NZ in August and September, the objective of which is to brief partners and customers on “what’s next” in the design and management of datacentre technology.

IN PICTURES: Nutanix's .NEXT channel event in Sydney (+20 photos)
IN PICTURES: EDGE 2015 sponsor debrief (+23 photos)

IN PICTURES: EDGE 2015 sponsor debrief (+23 photos)

Some of the sponsors of ARN's inaugural EDGE 2015 event got together at the ARN office for a debrieef of the event. Over some drinks and cheese, these attendees got an update on some key statistics that arose from the EDGE event and discussed potential topics and improvements that can be made at next year's event.

IN PICTURES: EDGE 2015 sponsor debrief (+23 photos)
IN PICTURES: ARN Distributor Roundtable, Sydney, 26.08.15 (+26 photos)

IN PICTURES: ARN Distributor Roundtable, Sydney, 26.08.15 (+26 photos)

ARN hosted a distributor roundtable at Cafe Del Mar in Sydney, at which attendees and their partners discussed the changing role of the traditional IT distributor. They spoke about the challenges of digital disruption, the blurring lines of the channel in the age of digital transformation, and examined the ever-evolving business models. This roundtable was sponsored by Distribution Central, Exclusive Networks, Rhipe, and Hemisphere Technologies. Photos by ARN Editorial Director, Mike Gee.

IN PICTURES: ARN Distributor Roundtable, Sydney, 26.08.15 (+26 photos) is a channel management ecosystem that automates all major aspects of the entire sales, marketing and service process, including data tracking, integrated learning, knowledge management and product lifecycle management.

Show Comments