Menu
Analysis: Did Apple spend $US2.3bn bailing out iPhone screen supplier Sharp?

Analysis: Did Apple spend $US2.3bn bailing out iPhone screen supplier Sharp?

Analyst Horace Dediu notes that Apple spent $US2.3 billion more than forecast and suggests that it was to bail out Sharp.

Apple may have spent $US2.3 billion bailing out Sharp earlier this year according to an analyst who has examined Apple's capital expenditure for the year.

Apple analyst Horace Dediu notes that Apple spent $US2.3 billion more than forecast on "product tooling, manufacturing process equipment and infrastructure" and suggests that "circumstantial evidence" leads him to believe this may have been to bail out Sharp.

Dediu notes that Apple's 2011 forecast for capital expenditure (capex) for 2012 was anticipated to be $8 billion, including $900 million for retail and $7.1 billion for product tooling and manufacturing process equipment. However, in its 10-K report released in October 2012 Apple revealed it had spent $10.3 billion in total. That's $865 million on retail (an under-spend of $35 million) and $9.5 billion on other areas including "including product tooling and manufacturing process equipment, and other corporate facilities and infrastructure". That's $2.3 billion higher than forecast.

Dediu also notices that: "The cash payments for capex were $2 billion lower than expenditures. This is a curious situation which was not highlighted in previous 10-K reports."

He notes that since "no new debt was booked" it is likely that Apple's over-spend was not paid for in cash but rather "some form of vendor financing".

He suggests that Apple "paid for some of the acquisitions through uncharacteristic or unorthodox means."

"The question is what was it spent on and why did it not go through the cash flow statement?" Dediu asks.

His answer: "Circumstantial [hypothetical, with no proof, he notes] evidence points to the asset being production equipment (or even a whole plant) previously owned by Sharp."

He notes that Sharp is a key supplier of screens to Apple and that it is "in financial distress".

Earlier this year there were reports that Foxconn was to invest in Sharp. That deal fell through however, states Dediu.

"My guess is that these attempts to shore up Sharp are directed by Apple to ensure both continuity of supply and a balanced supplier base (offsetting Samsung, another supplier.) If Sharp were to enter into some form of bankruptcy, the key plant(s) used in producing screens for Apple might be 'up for grabs' by creditors and they might be taken off-line, jeopardizing Apple's production capacity, irrespective of contractual obligations," suggests Dediu, with the financing for this deal " done through a swap of 'pre-orders'."

Read Dediu's complete analysts here.

Follow Karen Haslam on Twitter / Follow MacworldUK on Twitter

Related

Report: Samsung Display terminates LCD contract with Apple Ahead of Apple event, Sharp reveals 7-inch tablet with IGZO display Sharp can't make iPhone 5 screen fast enough, caused supply issues Will ditching Samsung parts mean Apple struggles to meet demand for iPhone 5? New iPhone 5 'won't include' Samsung chips or screen Next iPhone Screen Production Delayed By Sharp, Reports Say Foxconn, Sharp megadeal still on hold as negotiations roller coaster continues Sharp to supply LCD panels for Apple television, could launch this year Sharp investment and patent suggests Apple television

Follow Us

Join the ARN newsletter!

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags Appleconsumer electronicssharpsmartphoneshardware systemsiPhonetabletsiPad

Upcoming

Slideshows

IN PICTURES: Nutanix's .NEXT channel event in Sydney (+20 photos)

IN PICTURES: Nutanix's .NEXT channel event in Sydney (+20 photos)

Nutanix recently held its customer and channel event, .NEXT, in Sydney. The event, held at the Sheraton on the Park saw attendance from more than 150 channel and technology partners and customers. It was the first in a series of events Nutanix is holding in A/NZ in August and September, the objective of which is to brief partners and customers on “what’s next” in the design and management of datacentre technology.

IN PICTURES: Nutanix's .NEXT channel event in Sydney (+20 photos)
IN PICTURES: EDGE 2015 sponsor debrief (+23 photos)

IN PICTURES: EDGE 2015 sponsor debrief (+23 photos)

Some of the sponsors of ARN's inaugural EDGE 2015 event got together at the ARN office for a debrief of the event. Over some drinks and cheese, these attendees got an update on some key statistics that arose from the EDGE event and discussed potential topics and improvements that can be made at next year's event.

IN PICTURES: EDGE 2015 sponsor debrief (+23 photos)
IN PICTURES: ARN Distributor Roundtable, Sydney, 26.08.15 (+26 photos)

IN PICTURES: ARN Distributor Roundtable, Sydney, 26.08.15 (+26 photos)

ARN hosted a distributor roundtable at Cafe Del Mar in Sydney, at which attendees and their partners discussed the changing role of the traditional IT distributor. They spoke about the challenges of digital disruption, the blurring lines of the channel in the age of digital transformation, and examined the ever-evolving business models. This roundtable was sponsored by Distribution Central, Exclusive Networks, Rhipe, and Hemisphere Technologies. Photos by ARN Editorial Director, Mike Gee.

IN PICTURES: ARN Distributor Roundtable, Sydney, 26.08.15 (+26 photos)

iasset.com is a channel management ecosystem that automates all major aspects of the entire sales, marketing and service process, including data tracking, integrated learning, knowledge management and product lifecycle management.

Show Comments