Show and tell: Turnbull and broadband

Shadow Communications Minister tells a business forum lunch in Sydney his plan for broadband in Australia if the Coalition gains power

Shadow Communications Minister, Malcolm Turnbull, promises to bring fast broadband to all Australians faster than the National Broadband Network (NBN) should the Coalition seize power from Labor in Parliament.

The member for Wentworth was speaking at the Committee for Economic Development of Australia (CEDA) lunch in Sydney.

CEDA membership is comprised of hundreds of business groups and a number of them attended the event.

“At election, we’ll be able to say to people, particularly in the outer suburbs and indeed regional Australia

‘We will be able to get you very fast broadband more quickly than the NBN will deliver,” Turnbull said.

When asked to what his plans for broadband were if the Coalition was elected into parliament now, he said subjecting the NBN to a cost-benefit analysis by the Productivity Commission was at the top of his list.

Turnbull expects this process would take less than six months.

“It is pretty obvious what the conclusions would be,” he said. “I’m not trying to prejudge here but most people in the industry will tell you the likely approach will be a mix of technology.”

The Coalition has consistently attacked the fibre-to-the-premise (FTTP) NBN’s high cost.

At a Joint Committee of NBN parliamentary hearing in June, the Shadow Communications Minister had questioned the Productivity Commission on whether fibre-to-the-node (FTTN) would be cheaper to deploy than FTTP.

FTTN extends fibre to a node and connect to last mile copper that leads to a home whereas FTTP puts fibre directly into a premise.

Turnbull is in favour of using a mixed bag of technology for different situations. He promotes FTTP in greenfield sites and FTTN, fibre-to-the-curb or even wireless for other locations.

One thing he is adamant about is retaining existing hybrid fibre-coaxial (HFC) networks, which is part copper-based, owned by telcos such as Telstra and Optus.

The Labor government has sought to decommission existing HFC networks, along with aged copper networks, as part of the NBN plan. Telstra and Optus have both struck deals with NBN Co to do so.

“Decommissioning HFC networks is completely nuts; it’s economic vandalism,” Turnbull said. “These are networks with many years of like in them and are capable of delivering fast broadband.”

He said should the Coalition come to power, he would renegotiate with telcos regarding the shutdown of HFC networks.

Based on the Shadow Communications Minister’s plans, a lot of copper in the local telecommunications network will be retained which inevitably raises the issue of cost. Telstra owns most if not all of the last mile copper which connects to homes and businesses. Then there is the cost of maintaining copper networks.

While admitting copper networks are more expensive to maintain, it would be cheaper than splurging billions on deploying fibre to the majority of Australian premises, Turnbull said.

“Part of the difficulty [in the broadband] debate is the failure to recognise there are multiple ways of delivering fast broadband,” he said

Tags Committee for Economic Development of Australia (CEDA)National Broadband Network (NBN)nbn coCoalitionoptusgreenfield sitesbroadbandTelstraTelecommunicationsHFC NetworksFibre-to-the-Premise (FTTP)Malcolm Turnbull

More about etworkOptusProductivity CommissionTelstra Corporation

ARN Directory | Distributors relevant to this article




Yes Malcolm keep all the best speeds and connections for your lard-arsed mates in the cities and F**K regional and rural Australia.
Keep those regional and rural oafs back where they belong and give them all the copper they want.
The last thing we need is a carpet bagger lawyer trying to act like a geek and looking down patronisingly on on the rest of us.
Of course he wants a Productivity Commission enquiry so his tame lawyer mates can skew costings to his political benefit. After the Gretch affair his judgement is highly suspect at the best. It is obvious that he would wreck the NBN to further his chances to regain the liberal leadership



Mal baby. It's over, the deal is done. Get over it.
Find a portfolio that you understand like er, umm, there isn't one.
When it comes to communications the Libs have no idea. They stopped Telstra from laying optic fibre during the Howard days, they messed up digital TV big time where we see regional areas still waiting for the full digital services, they messed up Telstra by importing a bunch of managers who couldn't see pass 3G phones and made a totle balls up of digital radio.
It's a wonder we actually got passed the telegraph.

Tom brown


So big Mal wants to fracture our telecommunications network into a (hopefully modern) fibre structure feeding an existing antiquated decrepit copper infrastructure and still have to pay off Telstra.



Click on the links below!



Turnbull can go suck a lemon and join his mates at the commo party, we don't need his type.



Hello. This is a exalted forum. I wish to build lots of amazing friends.

See ya around



Are vending machines getting dumber?
Are vending machines limited to accepting cash by law?



checkout these collected exceptionally reasonably hotel accomidation websites and articles at all events the borough eilat for children



Do u know whats the Hardest Riddle in the world ?



el Silencio ha comenzado:)



Hello! Happy to be here, this is my personal first publish, hope later on times to get upon well.



Please delete this topic!



Horses eat hay.



Horses eat hay.



Please delete this topic!



I just got a new tattoo and tried H2ocean and it burned my skin and tattoo is scabbing..Anyone have any ideas on something that actually works?



Anyone know a good treatment for this for my son?




just signup here...still trying to figure out how things works here...




Anyone know a good treatment for this for my son?



Hi all,
I am Lindsay. Like my says I ve joined the community just now. I am keen to participate and contribute to this forum. I am basically a very opinionated person and love debating. I am a fitness freak and also a golf enthusiast. I am also in to social service and I contribute 10% of my income to trusts that educates African and Indian poor kids.

Nothing more.. looking forward to a happy time out here.



Hello! kdccdda interesting kdccdda site! I'm really like it! Very, very kdccdda good!



Hello! efcbdeb interesting efcbdeb site! I'm really like it! Very, very efcbdeb good!

Comments are now closed


Latest News

NEXTDC places sixth in Deloitte fast 500 APAC
John Grant to step down as Data#3 managing director
AWS re:Invent 2014 show floor (+25 photos)
Sophos launches Cloud Server Protection
More News
25 Nov
GovInnovate Summit
03 Dec
DC Infrastructure Solutions Professional
04 Dec
DC Infrastructure Delivery Professional
16 Dec
DC Infrastructure Solutions Professional
View all events