Telco NBN bill passes Senate – what now?

A lengthy Telstra structural separation process awaits after it received Senate approval today, according to analysts.

A lengthy Telstra structural separation process awaits after it received Senate approval today, according to analysts.

telco reform bill will see Telstra structurally separate its retail and wholesale arms.

It facilitates the $13.8 billion deal – initially valued at $11 billion - to decommission Telstra’s copper network and migrate customers onto the NBN.

Shareholders will still need to approve the non-binding agreement.

Click here to read What of Telstra if shareholders reject NBN deal?

The bill was on knife edge until the Federal Government agreed to release a condensed version of the NBN Co business case to appease key independents and win their support.

According to Ovum analyst, David Kennedy, it could be some time before the complete separation of Telstra becomes a reality.

“The bill doesn’t set out the specifics of separation,” he said. “What it does is set up a process for Telstra to make a separation plan, which then has to be approved by the ACCC and the Communications Minister, Senator Stephen Conroy.”

Based on structural separation cases in the UK and New Zealand, Kennedy expected a three-way split with one entity managing the copper access network, one will take care of the wholesale division while the other take on the retail division.

Separation should take at least 12 months, he said.

While the Coalition failed to thwart the bill, Market Clarity analyst, Richard Chirgwin, said it could still “demolish” the NBN; a job Opposition leader, Tony Abbott, assigned to Shadow Communications Minister, Malcolm Turnbull.

“[The bill] is a step in the process but even without NBN Co, the structural separation of Telstra has benefits for the telco industry,” Chirgwin said. “So it doesn’t make the NBN irreversible but the bill makes the network harder to eliminate.”

The point of no return for the Coalition’s anti-NBN plan would be when there are enough customers on the network, he said.

NBN Co predicts it will be able to be ready for a business-as-usual rollout and pass through 19 per cent of Australian households by December 2011.

“The success of the project would be the best defense against a political threat,” Chirgwin said. “The failure of execution will be the biggest threat to the NBN between now to whenever the point of no return might be.”

Since the release of the NBN Co business case summary, there has been questions raised about the stipulated price tag of the NBN.

According to the document, the NBN will cost $35.7 billion in capital expenditure, well below its original $43 billion budget.

But the Alliance for Affordable Broadband and the Opposition argue the numbers do not add up.

Tags Richard ChirgwinovumMarket Claritynational broadband networkdavid kennedyAlliance for Affordable BroadbandNBNTelstra

More about Australian Competition and Consumer CommissionetworkFederal GovernmentOvumTelstra Corporation

ARN Directory | Distributors relevant to this article




Who is really opposed to the NBN. I doubt that the Opposition members are and Turnbull has shown he really isn't ($10 million investment).
Abbott is because he opposes everything.
That leaves the one's that have the most to lose, Pay and commercial TV operators, (the US cable networks have already felt the blow), Cinemas, newspapers, Record companies, magazine publishers and anyone else who cannot gain from high speed internet.
Who wants it. Everybody else.
Who needs it. Every business that does not make money out of the above.
Who will love it. Content suppliers, advertisers, independent TV, Radio providers, every independent performer and me.

*Edited to correct acronym



+1, Kevin.

You are right about all the people who will benefit, though it may take a while before some of them realise it.

In the group opposing NBN are all the ones you said, plus perhaps the board/management and shareholders of some of the existing companies who seem to be concerned about any change to the structure of the industry.

Comments are now closed


Latest News

Oct 31
Over a quarter of Australians won’t bank on their mobile: Kaspersky
Oct 31
HDS A/NZ Partner Summit 2014 in Noosa (+15 photos)
Oct 31
The Google shakeup continues: Andy Rubin is out
Oct 31
Impact Systems boss wants to buy 10 resellers
More News
05 Nov
LIVE Webcast: Lessons Learned from the Biggest Security Breaches
05 Nov
vForum 2014
10 Nov
Ascom Myco Launch Event
11 Nov
DCIM Certified Solutions Professional
View all events