EDGE 2015 is starting in

Find out more EDGE 2015
Microsoft, Google and Yahoo! speak out in ISP filter consultation

Microsoft, Google and Yahoo! speak out in ISP filter consultation

The big boys submitted their views in the Internet filter report's public consultation process

Microsoft, Google and Yahoo! have taken different tacks during public consultation over the Federal Government’s Internet filtering.

A discussion paper on Broadband Minister, Senator Stephen Conroy’s mandatory ISP filtering bill was released for public comment last December. The document offered several options for determining how refused classification (RC) content should be categorised.

On March 23, the Department of Broadband released submissions received during the discussion paper’s public consultation process.

Senator Conroy stressed only RC material, including content that promotes or incites crime, will be blocked by the proposed Internet clean-feed. One option was to allow individuals to notify the Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA) of potential RC content, allowing the group to assess the material, which would then be forwarded to the Australia’s Classification Review Board.

In its submission, Microsoft supported all suspected RC material being referred back to the classification board, but saw the ACMA’s involvement as cumbersome.

“As a representative body of the Australian community, the Classification Board is a body capable of independently reviewing decisions of those public servants within ACMA, who may make initial decisions about potential RC content,” Microsoft stated. “In Microsoft’s opinion, all material that is the subject of complaint and evaluation by ACMA officials should be forwarded to the Classification Board for prompt review and decision.”

The software heavyweight however, was staunchly opposed to industry groups participating in the RC content classification process.

“Microsoft believes the public in general, and not ‘industry’ representatives, are the appropriate review group for both classified material and the classification process,” the company said. “The public is responsible for supervising and reviewing the operation of this system of censorship.”

Google went beyond commenting on how RC content should be categorised and criticised the filter itself.

“Our primary concern is that the scope of content to be filtered is too wide,” the search engine giant said in its submission. “[M]oving to a mandatory ISP-level filtering regime with a scope that goes well beyond [content such as child pornography] is heavy-handed and can raise genuine questions about restrictions on access to information.”

As well as issues surrounding content itself, Google flagged potential adverse effects on its users should infrastructure be filtered. As an example, it pointed to the Enex Testlab report last year, which said high traffic sites like Google’s subsidiary, YouTube, may cause performance bottlenecks.

For Yahoo! blocking websites dealing with controversial topics, such as euthanasia and abortion, was a major flaw.

“Clearly some of [the] content is controversial and, depending on one’s political beliefs, rather offensive,” the company said in its submission. “However, we maintain there is enormous value in this content being available to encourage debate and inform opinion.”

The search engine company also panned the current classification system underpinning the Internet filter proposal.

“The existing classification regime has developed in a piecemeal and reactionary manner with little regard to or basis upon empirical evidence around public attitudes or expert studies into how consumers interact with media, and particularly digital media,” it stated.

EDGE 2015:: For all the latest on EDGE 2015 including the keynote speakers visit the EDGE mini-site now

Follow Us

Join the ARN newsletter!

Error: Please check your email address.

Tags Broadband MinisterGoogleMicrosoftDepartment of Broadbandinternet filterSenator Stephen ConroyYahoo!youtube



In Pictures: Robots that cook, clean, sing and dance
Tech Hive

In Pictures: Robots that cook, clean, sing and dance

Cooking, learning language and doing the laundry are a few of the human skills demonstrated by.real humanoid bots featured in the National Geographic movie Robots.

In Pictures: Robots that cook, clean, sing and dance
IN PICTURES: OKI Data Australia partner event (+10 photos)
Business Products

IN PICTURES: OKI Data Australia partner event (+10 photos)

OKI recently hosted its ChannelOne dealer forum for its executive series channel partners to get together and learn about the company's new high-performance ES8400 A3 multifunction series printers. After a welcome and business overview from OKI Data Australia managing director, Dennie Kawahara, delegates were given a comprehensive overview of the new product, as well as an update on the latest marketing initiatives and software solutions, before being treated to live demos and a product showcase. Partners were also given a preview of OKI’s upcoming A3 digital LED white toner printer. With more than 60 delegates attending from all over the country, the day concluded with dinner at Casa Ristorante Italiano in Sydney and several delegates also participated in a friendly game of golf the following morning.

IN PICTURES: OKI Data Australia partner event (+10 photos)

iasset.com is a channel management ecosystem that automates all major aspects of the entire sales, marketing and service process, including data tracking, integrated learning, knowledge management and product lifecycle management.

Show Comments